Five Ways to Reframe Entitlement Reform

When referring to government programs in which Americans have a right to participate, such as Social Security and Medicare, the term “entitlement” used to mean a hard-won right of citizenship. These days, however, opponents of such programs use the word “entitlement” pejoratively in order to call these rights into question. The phrase “entitlement reform” is used to mean cuts to these programs. According to strict-father thinking, “the world doesn’t owe you a living,” so why should anyone receive money that they haven’t earned?

There’s a problem with this reasoning: it isn’t true.

For Social Security, Medicare, pensions, veterans’ benefits, and some other programs, the right to participate in these programs comes from having paid into their systems throughout our working careers or as deferred compensation. In other words, they are earned income. To cut these programs without the consent of their participants is to break the social contract. This would be morally wrong because hard-working Americans have earned these protections and have done nothing to deserve cuts to them. Also, many of us no longer could work to replace that income due to infirmity or disability, and cutting these protections would force many into undeserved poverty.

For programs into which Americans don’t pay as directly, such as SNAP (food stamps), we do contribute to them with our taxes. And even when Americans may not have paid much in income tax due to very low incomes, we do have a right to assistance from our country under the law, the teachings of Christianity and other religions,  and under Article 22 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. These are ways that Americans show we care for each other. While we may disagree about how best to express that caring, we should care and honor the rights of every American to participate in these programs when eligible.

Instead of speaking of entitlement reform, supporters of these programs should make clear what the bland phrase “entitlement reform” obscures. Five ways to reframe it are:

  • Theft of Americans’ deferred compensation
  • Cuts to older Americans’ income and healthcare in retirement
  • Keeping your social insurance premiums the same but cutting your future benefits (because Social Security and Medicare are insurance programs) and
  • Whacking away our right to security in old age, disability, or misfortune
  • A big pay cut for America

What do you think?

14 thoughts on “Five Ways to Reframe Entitlement Reform”

  1. This article is absolutely correct. Behind the conservative attack on contractual arrangements like Social Security or Medicare is the thought (fear?) that someone may be getting something for nothing. Though this is patently false, as the framer demonstrates, it has appeal to those who choose to believe that “big government” is the cause of all problems in the nation. It’s also rooted in a kind of radical individualism, which has no place for the pursuit of the common good represented by Social Security and Medicare.

  2. Velocidad critica
    Aparatos de calibración: clave para el funcionamiento suave y efectivo de las dispositivos.

    En el ámbito de la tecnología avanzada, donde la rendimiento y la confiabilidad del dispositivo son de máxima importancia, los dispositivos de equilibrado cumplen un rol vital. Estos equipos dedicados están desarrollados para balancear y regular elementos giratorias, ya sea en dispositivos de fábrica, vehículos de transporte o incluso en dispositivos de uso diario.

    Para los profesionales en soporte de dispositivos y los profesionales, operar con aparatos de equilibrado es esencial para proteger el operación estable y confiable de cualquier dispositivo rotativo. Gracias a estas herramientas avanzadas modernas, es posible minimizar sustancialmente las oscilaciones, el ruido y la esfuerzo sobre los cojinetes, extendiendo la duración de partes costosos.

    Igualmente importante es el papel que tienen los dispositivos de equilibrado en la servicio al consumidor. El soporte experto y el conservación continuo aplicando estos sistemas posibilitan proporcionar soluciones de óptima calidad, aumentando la satisfacción de los consumidores.

    Para los propietarios de negocios, la inversión en estaciones de equilibrado y sensores puede ser clave para optimizar la efectividad y desempeño de sus dispositivos. Esto es principalmente significativo para los emprendedores que gestionan modestas y modestas negocios, donde cada punto cuenta.

    También, los sistemas de equilibrado tienen una amplia uso en el campo de la prevención y el gestión de estándar. Facilitan localizar probables errores, reduciendo arreglos costosas y perjuicios a los equipos. Más aún, los información extraídos de estos equipos pueden usarse para mejorar procesos y incrementar la presencia en buscadores de consulta.

    Las campos de uso de los sistemas de equilibrado comprenden múltiples industrias, desde la producción de vehículos de dos ruedas hasta el control de la naturaleza. No afecta si se habla de extensas fabricaciones manufactureras o limitados talleres hogareños, los sistemas de balanceo son esenciales para asegurar un operación óptimo y sin detenciones.

  3. Awesome website you have here but I was wondering if you
    knew of any user discussion forums that cover the same topics
    discussed here? I’d really like to be a part of online community
    where I can get advice from other experienced people that share the same interest.

    If you have any recommendations, please let me know.
    Thanks!

  4. Just desire to say your article is as amazing. The clarity in your post is just cool and i can assume you are an expert
    on this subject. Fine with your permission let me
    to grab your RSS feed to keep up to date with forthcoming post.
    Thanks a million and please carry on the gratifying
    work.

Leave a Reply to zaym onlayn 92 Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *