I

Framing the Individual Mandate

63 Comments

Image

This refers to the expectation of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) that Americans that do not already have health insurance get it. Those that remain uninsured would pay a fine.

I think that supporters of the PPACA should avoid this phrase because it frames the expectation as big, bad government forcing people to do what they don’t want to do.

What if instead we frame having adequate health insurance as a civic duty? This duty helps ensure that all Americans can get the medical care we need . When we all have health insurance, we are taking care of both ourselves and our fellow Americans. That is right and responsible.

Shirking this duty would mean risking leaving medical bills unpaid and bankruptcy for ourselves. It also could mean higher costs for everyone else. This would be reckless and unfair. Because shirking imposes costs on others, it’s fair to charge a fine.

What difference would it make if we reframed this part of the PPACA from a mandate to a duty?
What difference would it make if we reframed this part of the PPACA from a mandate to a duty?

Instead of calling this part of PPACA the individual mandate, here are some potential alternatives:

  • The expectation of having health insurance (or health insurance expectation)
  • The duty of having health insurance (or health insurance duty)
  • The coverage expectation

What do you think this responsibility should be called?

63 thoughts on “Framing the Individual Mandate”

  1. “Mandate” is a word conservatives love to hate. When I was learning to drive in Iowa, I learned the state has (or had) a “financial responsibility law.” If you didn’t carry insurance you had to post a bond to prove that you had enough money to cover the costs of a potential accident. Any person who opts out of PPACA could be required to post a similar bond proving that s/he has enough money to cover the costs of his/her care in case of a catastrophic illness. Since those costs would run around a million dollars, it’s a motivation to opt in, and a lot cheaper.

    Reply

  2. I don’t like mandates, either. “Financial responsibility.” Hmmmmm. That does have a certain ring…. And of course, since car insurance and health insurance are both insurance, that’s a familiar and apt comparison. Good thinking!

    Reply
  3. Pingback: Senators Duckspeak Insurance Companies | Framology

  22. Оригинальный потолок стоимость натяжного потолка со световыми линиями со световыми линиями под заказ. Разработка дизайна, установка профиля, выбор цветовой температуры. Идеально для квартир, офисов, студий. Стильно, практично и с гарантией.

    Reply

  24. Мы предлагаем уборка домов в Москве и области, обеспечивая высокое качество, внимание к деталям и индивидуальный подход. Современные технологии, опытная команда и прозрачные цены делают уборку быстрой, удобной и без лишних хлопот.

    Reply

  26. Сериал «Уэнсдей» https://uensdey.com мрачная и захватывающая история о дочери Гомеса и Мортиши Аддамс. Учёба в Академии Невермор, раскрытие тайн и мистика в лучших традициях Тима Бёртона. Смотреть онлайн в хорошем качестве.

    Reply

  28. Флешка оптом https://usb-flashki-optom-24.ru/ деревянная купить и купить флешку На 128 гб недорого в Калининграде. Mini Usb флешка и флешки самые дешевые в Набережных Челнах. Флешки оптом смешные купить и флешку 64 гб купить

    Reply

  34. АО «ГОРСВЕТ» в Чебоксарах https://gorsvet21.ru профессиональное обслуживание объектов наружного освещения. Выполняем ремонт и модернизацию светотехнического оборудования, обеспечивая комфорт и безопасность горожан.

    Reply

  44. I have to say this post was certainly informative and contains useful content for enthusiastic visitors. I will definitely bookmark this website for future reference and further viewing. cheers a bunch for sharing this with us!

    Reply

  49. Цены на ремонт https://remontkomand.kz/ru/price квартир и помещений в Алматы под ключ. Узнайте точные расценки на все виды работ — от демонтажа до чистовой отделки. Посчитайте стоимость своего ремонта заранее и убедитесь в нашей прозрачности. Никаких «сюрпризов» в итоговой смете!

    Reply

  52. I would really like to appreciate the endeavors you cash in on written this article. I’m going for the similar best product from you finding out in the foreseeable future as well. Actually your creative writing abilities has urged me to begin my very own blog now. Genuinely the blogging is distributing its wings rapidly. Your write down is often a fine illustration showing it.

    Reply

  57. it is a really nice point of view. I usually meet people who rather say what they suppose others want to hear. Good and well written! I will come back to your site for sure!

    Reply

Leave a Reply to onlayn zaym 155 Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *